Letter to the Editor: Concerns Over Proposed Target

A letter to the editor.

The following is a letter to the editor from the "Friends of Burlington Canyon" with their top issues with the Gutierrez Company's proposed Target plan: 

Surprising that Burlington has not done independent study on a rezoning request of this scale

The traffic study was conducted by the developer themselves.  The Director of this Gutierrez project is Scot Weiss, who previous was Director of the company who did the study.  No independent traffic study was done by the town of Burlington.

The Gutierrez traffic study did not use peak traffic volume intervals.

VBH said they were peak volume data, but they measured the traffic in September not November to December months which have the peak traffic times.

Gutierrez’s traffic study did NOT include the effect they will have on the Route 95 extended entrance/exit ramps.

These extended entrance/exit ramps service both Route 95 and Route 3 and were part of a 2007 traffic study reported in 2010 by the BOSTON REGION METROPOLITAN PLANNING ORGANIZATION. This study showed during rush hours these roads already carry more than 200 cars / hour OVER their safe design limit.  The result is that traffic backs up onto Route 95 and Route 3 and there are far more accidents on these ramps than average ramps.

Gutierrez’s traffic study clearly states that a Target of this size would generate 1180 cars/HOUR.  Not daily – but hourly; and that most of this traffic would be added to these service roads.

How can Gutierrez ask the planning board members to recommend a plan that does not have emergency exit?

Gutierrez’s Traffic study ignored morning traffic impacts.

They indicated Target was a retail store and retail stores do not impact morning traffic.  Not true. Targets OPENS at 8:00 am and truck/personal traffic starts at least an hour before that. Big box stores like Target/Wal-Mart are NOT normal retail stores which typically open at 10:00.

They are directing a major traffic flow across Middlesex turnpike directly onto a congested ramp

One particularly onerous aspect of the plan is that they intend to route a large stream of traffic exiting target directly across Middlesex turnpike into a chronically congested on-ramp. This will regularly strand cars in the intersection and further block Middlesex Turnpike traffic.  A similar problem already exists where cars queueing up to turn in the H-Mart are stranded in the intersection and then block traffic entering from Adams street.

The Wheeler Road intersection is geographically constrained.

The fundamental problem is that there is no reasonably priced strategy that works at that location because of the ridged site constraints. The Wheeler / Middlesex intersection site make any reasonably prices mitigation impossible; there is simply not enough real-estate available to lay down the needed asphalt.  Any truly effective traffic mitigation will involve new overpasses and / or added access ramps which would make the whole project financially unworkable.

Reduction in Burlington home values

Location is key to Real Estate values, and this will make our location far less attractive.

Our lost housing values will not affect Gutierrez balance sheet but is very real to us.

As real estate values decrease so will Burlington’s tax revenues.

Consider just the 300 Burlington residences south of Rt 95 and 300 home just north of Route 95 that access Route 95 via Middlesex Turnpike.

Assuming they are average prices homes for Burlington:  $400K.

600 homes *  $400K  = $240M  in real-estate value.

Assume a 20% loss in value do to their now far less desirable location.

$240M * 20% loss in value:  $48M loss in Burlington real-estate value.

The reputation that Burlington is undesirable place to live because of the horrible traffic is likely going to affect Burlington home values even far from this traffic quagmire.

Loss in residential tax revenue

A 20% reduction in home value of just 600 homes would result in an annual loss in tax revenue:  $552K so the $750K that Gutierrez promise should be highly discounted.

Burlington Resident March 30, 2012 at 11:55 AM
So what should we do. Traffic is a nightmare down there, this might be the only chance to fix this. The state is selling the land and they are going to sell it to someone else who will keep it as RO. If this happens the new developer and state won’t be willing to help out with the traffic. As for the loss in tax revenue. Sounds like you are trying to scare Burlington residents. This is your opinion, right?
Robert Gallagher March 30, 2012 at 02:03 PM
How does this compare to the push back Dave and Busters got? Seems that was surrounding traffic concerns as well. So I guess why is Target okay but Dave and Busters not? Do we all believe that Target will not impact traffic? I agree the traffic is a nightmare there already - is this our chance to really "fix" this? We will be in a different set of circumstances and challenges if this goes to an "unknown" developer. I'm on the fence still. Whatever happened to Dave and Busters anyway?
J. Parker March 30, 2012 at 07:18 PM
The property should stay RO. A development of homes is far better than a big box store and more restaurants. "Build it and they will come"....More traffic, more trucks, more glaring lights shining into peoples homes, more noise and more crime. The "Canyon" is not the most desirable place for anything really. We are surrounded over here by business and shopping centers. People are throwing their trash out along Muller & Blanchard Rds. Enough is Enough ! If anyone thinks that the nightmare traffic will be made any better, they are kidding themselves. It is now something we have to put up with due to over development in a one mile area. Bad planning ! Where has everyone's head been ? We, that live on this side of town, realize that those living on the other side could never fathom our dilemma. You get the perks, and we get the pain. Sorry, it's just the truth.
Wayne Wisner April 02, 2012 at 03:12 PM
Adams St is already littered with trash from Burger King, McDonalds, Dunkin Donuts, DeAngelos and I don't see the town doing anything to clean up the mess.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something